How much should you spend on an engagement ring? Can you mix metals? Are bigger diamonds better? Experts tackle the biggest wedding jewellery myths

Newlywed couple posing outdoors, with the bride wearing an off-the-shoulder wedding dress and long lace-edged veil.

The bride wears an 18ct white-gold 6ct diamond line necklace, £13,100; Esme platinum 1.51ct diamond solitaire ring, £17,250; 18ct white-gold wedding ring, £POA; and 18ct white-gold sapphire-and-diamond hoop earrings, £1,825, all Laings.

How much should you spend on an engagement ring? Can you mix gold and platinum? Are bigger diamonds always better? And do wedding bands actually need to match?

Buying engagement rings and wedding rings can involve a surprising amount of conflicting advice. Some jewellery ‘rules’ are useful, but others are outdated traditions, clever marketing or simply myths that have been repeated so often they sound like fact.

And while plenty of wedding decisions will be forgotten once the day is over, your rings are different. You could be wearing them every day for decades, so it’s worth knowing what actually matters before you buy.

We asked jewellery experts to tackle some of the biggest engagement ring myths, wedding ring myths and diamond misconceptions – from the three-month salary rule to mixing metals and leaving your wedding-ring shopping until the last minute.

Wedding jewellery myths: the quick answers

Do you need to spend three months’ salary on an engagement ring? No. There’s no correct amount to spend.

Can you mix metals in a wedding ring stack? Yes, although the hardness of different metals is worth considering.

Is bespoke jewellery always more expensive? No. Bespoke can allow you to control where your budget is spent.

Can diamonds chip or break? Yes. Diamonds are extremely hard, but they aren’t indestructible.

Is a higher-carat diamond always better? No. Cut, colour and clarity also affect its appearance.

Are diamonds the most expensive gemstones? Not necessarily. Rare sapphires and rubies can also command high prices.

When should you buy wedding rings? Don’t leave it until the final weeks, particularly if you need alterations or a bespoke design.

Do couples need matching wedding bands? No. Each ring can reflect the wearer’s individual style.

Is higher-carat gold too soft for wedding rings? Not necessarily. It simply wears differently over time.

Bride wearing a delicate diamond engagement ring and wedding band in a close-up bridal jewellery portrait.

Kelvin Collection Trilogy platinum and diamond ring, £3,360, and lab-grown diamond twist platinum channel-set wedding ring with baguette and round-cut lab-grown diamonds (0.89ct total), £1,870, Blair and Sheridan. (Photo: Craig and Eva Sanders)

Myth 1: An engagement ring should cost three months’ salary

The verdict: myth. There’s no set amount you should spend on an engagement ring.

The idea that an engagement ring should cost several months’ salary has been passed down for generations, but it isn’t a financial rule you need to follow.

The concept grew from highly successful diamond advertising during the 20th century. Before De Beers declared that “A diamond is forever”, diamonds weren’t necessarily the automatic choice for a proposal that they later became.

So, how much should you spend on an engagement ring?

There’s no correct figure. Your engagement-ring budget should be whatever you’re comfortable spending, taking into account your own finances and priorities.

There are engagement rings available across a huge range of price points, so setting a budget first can make the search considerably easier.

Debbie Murdoch at Glasgow jeweller Blair and Sheridan sums it up neatly: an engagement ring should be “a celebration – not a source of stress”.

Myth 2: You can’t mix metals in engagement and wedding rings

The verdict: false. You can mix yellow gold, white gold, platinum and other metals – but think about how the rings will wear together.

Matching metals can create a cohesive wedding-ring stack, but your engagement ring and wedding band don’t have to be made from the same material.

“A beautifully matched suite of rings in the same metal gives a sense of harmony and refinement, creating a seamless and elegant look – but this is by no means the only way to wear jewellery,” says Lauren Byars at Laings. “Engagement rings, wedding bands and eternity rings should be chosen based on your personal taste and the pieces you love most. If that means mixing metals, that’s fine – it can be a wonderfully considered and stylish choice.”

If you’re planning a mixed-metal ring stack, there is one practical point to consider: different metals have different levels of hardness.

Lauren explains: “Some softer metals may suffer wear when they sit directly against other, harder metals. But there are thoughtful ways to combine different looks while protecting your pieces and still allowing for personal expression.”

A jeweller can advise on how two particular metals and ring designs are likely to sit together over time.

Whichever combination you prefer, Rachel Porter at James Porter & Son in Glasgow says “what matters most is that the two rings work well together visually and physically”.

“Mixing yellow gold with platinum or white gold, for example, can create a very intentional two-tone look and it’s one we’re seeing more and more. It can also make it easier to tie the rings in with other jewellery or watches you already own.”
Bespoke pear-shaped emerald engagement ring with diamond detailing stacked with a decorative mixed-metal wedding band.

Blair and Sheridan designed this engagement ring and wedding band set. It’s made of platinum and 18ct red gold, with diamonds, sapphires and a stunning Zambian emerald. It costs £15,000.

Myth 3: Bespoke engagement rings and wedding bands are always more expensive

The verdict: not necessarily. Bespoke jewellery can actually give you more control over your budget.

It’s easy to assume that commissioning a bespoke engagement ring or wedding band will automatically cost more than buying a ready-made design.

A particularly complex handmade ring, unusual setting or expensive gemstone can increase the price, of course, but bespoke doesn’t automatically mean expensive.

Rachel at James Porter & Son explains: “Going bespoke can be an efficient way to work with your budget, as it allows you to control the metal, gemstones and features, rather than paying for something you don’t want.”

It can also be useful if you already know exactly what matters to you. Instead of choosing the closest available ring in a shop, you can prioritise the elements you value most – whether that’s the gemstone, metal, setting or shape – and create something that feels more personal.

Bespoke wedding ring design sketches and handwritten notes beside a pen during the jewellery design process.

The bespoke journey at Blair and Sheridan begins with rings being sketched out by the in-house design team.

Myth 4: Diamonds are indestructible

The verdict: definitely a myth. Diamonds are extremely hard, but they can still be damaged.

Diamonds are widely recognised as the hardest naturally occurring substance, which can make it sound as though a diamond engagement ring is virtually impossible to damage, but that isn’t the case.

“They can still chip, crack or fracture if they receive impact in the wrong place,” warns Rachel at James Porter.

That means your diamond ring still needs looking after, particularly during activities where the stone or setting could take a knock.

You are advised to remove your ring “when doing activities where the stones could be knocked, exposed to harsh chemicals or subjected to unnecessary pressure,” says Rachel Wood at Orkney-based jeweller Sheila Fleet.

Regular jewellery checks are worthwhile too. Having the ring examined periodically means a jeweller can check that the stone remains secure in its setting.

Myth 5: A higher-carat diamond is always better

The verdict: no. Bigger doesn’t automatically mean better when choosing a diamond.

Carat describes the weight of a diamond, but it’s only one factor in how the finished stone looks. A larger diamond isn’t necessarily more brilliant or visually impressive than a smaller one; the cut, colour and clarity all matter too.

The “cut, colour and clarity all play a part in how a diamond looks and performs,” explains Rachel at Sheila Fleet. “A beautifully cut smaller diamond can appear more lively and brilliant than a larger diamond with a poorer cut.”

Rachel at James Porter & Son agrees: “Two diamonds of identical weight will look noticeably different if one of them is not cut correctly,” she points out.

Rather than choosing purely on carat weight, consider how the stone looks in the ring, how it performs in the light and whether it works with your preferred design and budget. The ‘best’ diamond isn’t necessarily the biggest one, but the one that works best for the person wearing it.

Oval diamond engagement ring paired with a diamond-set wedding band and photographed among white calla lilies.

Platinum 0.70ct oval-cut diamond solitaire, £4,175, and platinum 1.25ct diamond wedding band, £3,625, Laings.

Myth 6: Diamonds are always the best – and most expensive – engagement-ring gemstone

The verdict: they aren’t your only option, and they aren’t automatically the most expensive.

Diamonds remain a popular choice for engagement rings, but there’s no requirement to choose one. Other gemstones can work beautifully – and some can be extremely valuable in their own right.

“Sapphires and rubies can also be pricey when you get the right combination of rarity, colour, size and origin,” says Rachel from James Porter & Son.

Sapphires are also a particularly practical alternative for rings designed to be worn regularly.

“The traditional blue sapphire is elegant and timeless but it is not the only option. You get sapphires in a beautiful spectrum of pinks, greens and even yellows, giving you the romance and individuality of a coloured gemstone while still offering the strength needed for day-to-day wear.”

Coloured gemstones can also be a way to make an engagement ring feel more individual, whether you choose a sapphire, ruby or even a coloured diamond.

Myth 7: You can leave buying your wedding rings until the last minute

The verdict: risky. Give yourself enough time for ordering, sizing, alterations or bespoke work.

Wedding rings can easily slip down an increasingly long wedding-planning checklist, but if possible, don’t leave shopping for them until the final few weeks before the wedding.

“Even if you find the perfect ring on your first shopping trip, ordering the correct size or having something altered can add weeks to the usual timescale,” says Rachel at James Porter & Son.

Your engagement ring can also influence the process.

“And if your engagement ring has a unique shape or setting, your wedding band may need to be designed specifically to sit perfectly alongside it,” says Debbie at Blair and Sheridan.

A bespoke wedding ring will naturally require additional time. That process can include the “design, consultation, CAD, making, stone-setting and finishing,” Debbie adds.

Given that your wedding rings are intended to last far beyond the wedding itself, they’re worth treating as more than a last-minute purchase.

Personalised wedding rings with blue detailing and an engraved wedding date displayed together on wood.

Runic dress ring in Skaill Enamel, from £222, and Matrix band in sterling silver, from £143, plus engraving from £25 per ring, Sheila Fleet. 

Myth 8: Couples must have matching wedding rings

The verdict: absolutely not.

Your wedding bands can match if that feels right for you, but there’s no requirement for them to be identical – or even particularly similar.

Matching metals, shapes or details can create a connection between two rings, but each person can still choose the style they actually want to wear.

“Matching metals can create a beautiful sense of unity, allowing the pieces to feel connected as a pair,” says Lauren at Laings. “But individuality is just as important. Each ring should reflect the personal style of the wearer and feel significant to them, creating a lasting symbol of love that feels both considered and entirely personal.”

Exactly the same principle applies to an engagement ring and wedding band: they can form a perfectly matched bridal set, contrast deliberately or sit somewhere in between. The important thing is that the rings work for the person wearing them.

Two contrasting wedding rings displayed together on a wooden slice with natural feather details.

‘Of Eachother’ rings with the groom’s in 18ct yellow gold with a white-gold-plated imprint, and the bride’s in 18ct white gold, £POA, Christina Rose Leon Jewellery.

Myth 9: Higher-carat gold is too soft for a wedding or engagement ring

The verdict: not necessarily. Higher-carat gold wears differently, but that doesn’t automatically make it unsuitable.

One common source of confusion when shopping for wedding jewellery is the word carat itself. For diamonds, carat describes weight. For gold, carat indicates purity.

For example, 24ct gold is 99.99% pure. Because pure gold is relatively soft, it is often mixed with other metals to create different alloys. In 18ct gold, 75% of the metal is gold, with the remainder made up of other metals.

Does that mean higher-carat gold is unsuitable for an engagement or wedding ring? Not necessarily.

“A higher carat doesn’t make it impractical, it just means it will wear differently over time,” says Rachel at James Porter & Son.

When choosing between different metals, durability, appearance and how you want the ring to age are all worth discussing with your jeweller. Both 18ct gold and platinum can offer a balance of durability and richness for rings designed for regular wear.

And whichever metal you choose, looking after it matters. Routine cleaning, checking and polishing can help keep wedding and engagement rings in good condition for years to come.

What should you actually look for when buying wedding jewellery?

Ignore the idea that there’s one ‘right’ way to buy an engagement ring or wedding band.

Start with your own priorities: your budget, personal style, lifestyle and how you want the rings to work together.

Ask questions about the metal, gemstone, setting and durability, and try on combinations rather than assuming they need to match. If you’re commissioning something bespoke or need a shaped wedding band, be sure to build enough time into your wedding-planning schedule.

Your rings are among the few wedding purchases you may still be wearing decades after the last glass of fizz has been poured. That’s why it’s so important to choose the ones that work for you – not the ones an outdated rule says you ought to have.

Wedding jewellery FAQs

There’s no fixed amount you should spend on an engagement ring. Set a budget that works comfortably for your finances rather than following rules based on salary.

Yes. Different metals can be mixed to create a two-tone ring stack. However, because metals vary in hardness, it’s worth asking a jeweller how your chosen rings will wear when placed directly beside one another.

Not always. Bespoke jewellery allows you to choose where the budget goes by selecting the metal, gemstones and design features that matter most to you.

Yes. Although diamonds are extremely hard, they can still chip, crack or fracture if they receive an impact in a vulnerable area.

No. Diamond carat measures weight, not overall quality. Cut, colour and clarity also affect how a diamond looks, and a well-cut smaller stone can appear more brilliant than a poorly cut larger one.

Sapphires and rubies are among the alternatives discussed by our experts. Sapphires are available in colours including traditional blue, pink, green and yellow.

No. Couples can choose identical wedding bands, coordinate certain elements or select completely different rings that reflect their individual tastes.

Allow enough time for ordering the correct size, alterations and any bespoke design work. If your engagement ring has an unusual shape, you may also need additional time for a wedding band to be designed around it.

Yes. Higher-carat gold isn’t automatically impractical for everyday wear. It will simply wear differently over time, and a jeweller can advise on the most appropriate metal for your lifestyle and preferred design.

Share this article:

Previous article

How to personalise your wedding jewellery: bespoke rings, engraving and heirloom ideas